Back to Blog

Stop Guessing Volume: The Real Hypertrophy Threshold for 2025

Stop Guessing Volume: The Real Hypertrophy Threshold for 2025
1/12/2026
#Volume Optimization#PUOS#Stretch Training#RIR Management#Hypertrophy Science

The Volume Trap: Why More Sets Often Mean Less Gain

For years, the bro-science prescription has been simple: if you're not doing 20 hard sets for chest every week, you're leaving gains on the table. But recent research from Florida Atlantic University and meta-analyses by Brad Schoenfeld reveals a precise point of diminishing returns that changes everything.

This concept is called the PUOS - Point of Undetectable Outcome Superiority. It's the exact moment where adding another set to your workout stops providing measurable benefit and starts cannibalizing your recovery.

The Science Behind Session Volumes

A 2025 meta-regression published in the Journal of Applied Physiology analyzed data from hundreds of lifters and found muscle growth plateaus after approximately 11 fractional sets per muscle per session. Beyond this threshold, the extra metabolic stress and systemic fatigue outweigh the mechanical tension benefits.

In practical terms: If you're doing 5 exercises for chest at 3 sets each (15 total sets), the last 4 sets are likely junk volume - burning glycogen without stimulating additional growth.

Weekly vs. Session Volume: The Critical Distinction

While 20-30 total weekly sets per muscle group remains the sweet spot for most intermediate lifters, how you distribute these sets matters profoundly. The 2024 research by Milo Wolf's team demonstrated that splitting these across 2-3 sessions dramatically outperforms marathon sessions.

The Protocol:

  • Chest: 10 sets Monday (heavy compounds) + 8 sets Thursday (stretch-focused accessories)
  • Legs: 9 sets Tuesday (squat emphasis) + 9 sets Friday (deadlift/hip hinge)

This distributes fatigue while maintaining weekly volume, allowing you to train each muscle while it's still supercompensated from the previous session.

The New Rules of Proximity to Failure

Here's where the GymNotes philosophy of data-driven training becomes critical. The 2025 research confirms that mechanical tension is king, but how you achieve it determines efficiency.

RIR Protocol for 2025:

  • Compound lifts: 1-2 Reps In Reserve (RIR)
  • Stretch-focused isolation: 0-1 RIR
  • Lengthened partials: 0 RIR

The key insight: You don't need every set to failure. In fact, training to absolute failure on compounds creates unnecessary fatigue that reduces your capacity for the high-quality volume you actually need.

Stretch-Mediated Hypertrophy: The 43% Advantage

A 2024 study on calf training revealed something remarkable: Trainees performing seated calf raises (stretched position emphasis) saw 43.3% greater hypertrophy compared to those doing standing calf raises with identical volume.

This isn't isolated to calves. The stretched position creates unique tension on muscle fibers that triggers superior growth signaling.

Exercise Selection Matrix

High Stretch Emphasis (Prioritize These):

  • Romanian Deadlifts > Conventional Deadlifts for hamstrings
  • Deficit Push-ups > Flat Bench for chest stretch
  • Seated Calf Raises > Standing
  • Overhead Cable Extensions > Lying Triceps Extensions

Full ROM Still Works: The same study confirmed full ROM training produces excellent results, but if you're looking for maximum efficiency from limited time, prioritizing stretch positions offers an edge.

The Minimalist's Data Stack

The GymNotes approach: Track only what predicts future success. Based on 2025 research, here are your mandatory metrics:

  1. Weekly Set Count Per Muscle - Stay in 20-30 range
  2. Session Set Cap - Stop at 11-12 hard sets per muscle per day
  3. Average RIR - Maintain 1-2 for compounds, 0-1 for isolation
  4. Stretch Position Quality - Rate sets on tension in lengthened state (1-5 scale)

Implementing This Tomorrow

Step 1: Audit your current log. Count total weekly sets per muscle group.

Step 2: Identify your PUOS point. If you're doing 15+ sets per session for any muscle, you're likely in junk volume territory.

Step 3: Redistribute. Move 3-4 sets to a second session per week.

Step 4: Adjust RIR targets. Remove 1-2 reps from your working sets on compounds to hit the 1-2 RIR range.

Step 5: Prioritize stretch. Swap at least one exercise per muscle group to emphasize the lengthened position.

The Stoic's Perspective on Training Smarter

This research validates a fundamental GymNotes principle: Constraints breed creativity. By accepting that more isn't better, you force yourself to optimize the quality of every single set.

The lifter who does 9 high-quality sets with perfect stretch tension and precise RIR management will outperform the one grinding through 18 sloppy sets every time.

Your training log becomes a precision instrument, not a volume counter. Every entry answers: "Did this set provide mechanical tension in the stretched position close to failure?" If not, it doesn't belong in your program.

Action Items for Your Next Session

  1. Calculate your current PUOS: Total sets per muscle / sessions per week. If above 11 per session, reduce.

  2. Select one stretch-focused swap: Example: Replace leg press with deep split squats.

  3. Log RIR explicitly: Not just "3x10 @ 185", but "3x10 @ 185, RIR 2, RIR 1, RIR 1".

  4. Set a session cap: When you hit 11 hard sets for a muscle group, end that portion of your workout.

The era of guessing is over. The data is clear: smarter volume, precise RIR management, and stretch emphasis deliver superior results in less time. Your training log isn't just tracking history - it's predicting future gains.